Jeremy Allen White Supports Rumored Girlfriend Molly Gordon at NYC Screening of Her New Movie

After months of laying low, Molly Gordon and Jeremy Allen White are once again fueling romance rumors.

The actors, who star as love interests on The Bear, spent an evening together in New York City on Tuesday, July 22, as White, 34, showed up to support Gordon, 29, and her new film.

He was a special guest of the actress, along with Owen Thiele, at Sony Pictures Classics and The Cinema Society’s screening of Oh, Hi! at the Roxy Cinema and Jimmy.

White attended both the screening and afterparty with Gordon’s parents, with whom he appeared to be familiar.

Following the screening of the movie, which Gordon stars in alongside Logan Lerman and produced, the actress celebrated with White, Thiele, Lerman and his fiancée Ana Corrigan.

White and Gordon kept things lowkey but were spotted grabbing each other’s hands at several moments throughout the evening.

Speculation about the costars’ off-camera relationship began last September when they were photographed kissing in L.A.

Photos emerged of White and Gordon sharing several kisses — and a tight embrace — on Sept. 25 last year.

They had their arms wrapped around each other as they kissed and hugged during the low-key outing, which came after White had previously been linked to singer Rosalía, with whom he was first spotted in October 2023 and was last seen with in July 2024.

A source later told PEOPLE that Gordon and White had “intense chemistry” on the set of The Bear that developed into something more.

After they were seen kissing, a source said that the costars had only recently started “hanging out romantically.”

“There were set rumors early on that they had intense chemistry even when not filming,” the source said.

White “really seems into Molly,” the insider continued.

“She spends time at his house. They go on lunch dates and seem to have a great time. They’re affectionate, often in deep conversations and seem curious to get to know each other better.”

Fatherhood remains a priority for the actor, though, who shares daughters Ezer and Dolores with his ex-wife, Addison Timlin. White is “very involved with his kids,” the source said, and “often takes them out for activities.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Oh, Hi! hits cinemas July 25, and The Bear can be streamed on Hulu.